2005-06: Ciolino posted an 8-7 overall record in the fall season, including a 5-3 mark in doubled play. He advanced to the quarterfinals at the ITA regional championships and teamed with Colin Flynn to advance to the doubles semifinals. Ciolino currently ranks sixth all- time in overall wins (83), fifth in singles wins (44), sixth in doubles wins (39). 
 
2004-05: Ciolino posted the second 25 win season of his collegiate career as a junior, playing primarily first singles and second doubles. He recorded wins in both singles and doubles play in the Empire 8 Quarterfinals against Elmira and posted doubles wins against Nazareth (semifinals) and RIT (finals) en route to being selected a second-team Empire 8 all-star at both singles and doubles. He won singles and doubles matches against Nazareth, posting his first singles win of the year. He advanced to the quarterfinals of the ITA championships with two singles victories. 
 
2003-04: Ciolino, a first-team Empire 8 selection in doubles and a second-team all-conference singles selection, recorded a 15-31 overall record with eight singles wins and seven doubles wins. He played at primarily at second singles and first doubles, ending the season at first singles. Ciolino won a singles match and two doubles matches at the Empire 8 championships, including both singles and doubles in the quarterfinals against Utica. He won singles and doubles matches against Elmira and St. John Fisher. Ciolino recorded Ithaca’s only win in singles against Hobart (6-7, 6-2, 11-9). He won two of three doubles matches at Nazareth’s Flower City Tournament in the fall. 
2002-03: Ciolino was named Empire 8 Rookie of the Year and was a second-team conference all-star. His 23 singles wins broke the school record held by Jean-Jamil Rojer (22 wins, 1998-99). Ciolino posted an overall record of 35-18, including 12 doubles wins. He played primarily at first doubles and fourth singles. His first win in singles and doubles came against Nazareth. At the St. Lawrence Ice Breaker tournament Ciolino advanced to the finals in singles and doubles. In the spring portion of the season he won 14 of 16 singles matches, including 11 straight to end the season. 
High School: Ciolino, Newark Star Ledger West Jersey Player of the Year in 2001 and 2002, played for coach Jeff Hughes at Sparta High School. 
Personal: A business administration major, he is the son of Thomas and Dorothy Ciolino.