Ithaca College Athletics

Charles Baker/HB; AP Honorable Mention

1947

Mike Nicholas/T; AP

1958

Mike Angelo/C; AP Honorable Mention

Charles Boots/T; Williamson Honorable Mention

Dick Carmean/HB; AP Honorable Mention

1959

Mike Angelo/C; Williamson Honorable Mention, AP Honorable Mention

Charles Boots/T; Williamson Honorable Mention

1960

Jack Cashman/E; AP Honorable Mention

Jim Rafferty/E; AP Honorable Mention

1961

Ron Segal/E; AP Honorable Mention

1962

John Miller/G; AP Honorable Mention

Bill O’Dell/HB; Williamson First Team

1963

Sam Curko/G; Williamson First Team

1964

Len Tyler/E; AP Second Team

1965

Len Tyler/E; AP Honorable Mention

1968

Jim Ryan/LB; AP Honorable Mention

1969

Gary Worden/C; AP Honorable Mention, AFCA Honorable Mention

1970

Doug Campbell/QB; AP Honorable Mention

1971

Doug Campbell/QB; AP Honorable Mention

Bob Wojnar; AP Honorable Mention

1972

Bob Wojnar; AFCA, AP Honorable Mention

1974

Jerry Boyes/QB; AP Honorable Mention

Dave Remick/FB; AFCA, AP Honorable Mention

1975

Jerry Boyes/QB; AP Honorable Mention

Bill Bryant/SE; AP Honorable Mention

Larry Czarnecki/DT; AP First Team, AFCA

Ron DiMartino/LB; AP Honorable Mention

Jim Szczerba/DE; AP Honorable Mention

1977

Scott Colton/FS; AP Honorable Mention

John Schiemann/DT; AP Honorable Mention

1978

Scott Colton/FS; AP Third Team

John Laper/LB; AP Honorable Mention

Matt Mees/FB; AP Honorable Mention

John Schiemann/CB; AP Honorable Mention

1979

Bill George/C; SID First Team

John Laper/LB; AFCA First Team, Mizlou

John Nicolo/RB; SID Second Team

1980

Jim Duncan/SE; SID Honorable Mention

Bob Ferrigno/FB; AFCA, SID First Team, AP Third Team

Carl Guidotti/DT; SID First Team

Jimmy Hoffman/DT; SID Second Team, AP Honorable Mention

Allan MacDonald/OT; SID First Team, AP Honorable Mention

Bill Rosecrans/LB; SID First Team, AP Honorable Mention

1982

Roy Anderson/SS; SID Honorable Mention

John Koob/RB; SID Honorable Mention

Rick Pardy/OG; SID Honorable Mention

Bill Sheerin/NG; SID Second Team

Dave Stone/LB; SID Second Team

1983

Roy Anderson/SS; SID Third Team

Gerry Gerbis/LB; SID Honorable Mention

Pete Savage/OT; SID Honorable Mention

Bill Sheerin/NG; SID Third Team

Dave Stone/LB; SID Honorable Mention

1984

Joe DeBellis/G; AP Third Team, SID Honorable Mention

Bill Decker/CB; SID Second Team

Brian Dougherty/SS; SID Second Team

Gerry Gerbis/LB; SID Third Team

Bill Sheerin/NG; AFCA, SID Honorable Mention

Tim Torrey/LB; SID Second Team

1985

Steve Brett/OT; SID First Team

Brian Dougherty/SS; SID Honorable Mention

Kevin Farrell/CB; SID Second Team

Steve Kass/QB; SID Honorable Mention

Pete Minturn/SE; SID Honorable Mention

Dave Molee/DT; SID Honorable Mention

Steve Sweeney/DT; SID Honorable Mention

Tim Torrey/LB; AFCA, AP First Team, SID First Team, Football Gazette First Team

Rich Wageman/OT; SID First Team

Dan Welkley/FS; SID Honorable Mention

1986

Bob Garone/G; SID Third Team, AP, Football Gazette Second Team

George Mack/SE; SID Second Team

Joe Marra/LB; SID Second Team

Bob Mason/DT; SID Second Team

Dave Molee/DT; SID Honorable Mention

1987

Bob Mason/DT; SID Third Team, AP Honorable Mention, Football Gazette Second Team

Ray DeCarr/QB; SID Honorable Mention, AP Honorable Mention

Tom Decker/G; Football Gazette Second Team

Daegan Gray/LB; AP Honorable Mention

Marc Hudak/C; SID Honorable Mention

Joe Marra/LB; SID Honorable Mention, AP Honorable Mention

1988

Lee Byrne/FS; AP Honorable Mention

Dan Feldman/LB; SID Second Team, Football Gazette Third Team

Daegan Gray/LB; SID Second Team, AP Honorable Mention, Football Gazette Second Team

Marc Hudak/C; SID First Team, AP Second Team, Football Gazette Second Team

Paul Parker/FB; Football Gazette Third Team

Mike Scott/RB; SID First Team, AP Honorable Mention, Football Gazette Second Team

Rich Smith/DT; SID First Team, Football Gazette First Team, AP Second Team

1989

Lee Byrne/FS; SID First Team, Football Gazette First Team

Dan Feldman/LB; SID First Team, Football Gazette First Team

Ken Hammel/SE; Football Gazette Honorable Mention

Matt Herbst/LB; Football Gazette Third Team

Ralph Jones/DT; Football Gazette Honorable Mention

Evan Marcus/OT; Football Gazette Second Team

Tim Rice/OT; SID Honorable Mention, Football Gazette Honorable Mention

1990

Chris Colloca/LB; SID Third Team, Football Gazette Second Team

Ken Hammel/SE; SID Honorable Mention

Brian Orzolek/OT; Football Gazette Second Team

Joe Williams/FS; SID Third Team

Jeff Wittman/FB; SID First Team, Football Gazette Second Team

1991

Nick Ismailoff/SE; SID Third Team, Football Gazette Second Team

Keith Linsey/C; SID Second Team, Football Gazette Second Team

Billie Mays Jr./LB; SID Second Team, AP Third Team, Football Gazette Honorable Mention

Joe Palladino/SS; Football Gazette Third Team

Chris White/OT; Football Gazette Honorable Mention

Todd Wilkowski/QB; SID Second Team, Football Gazette Honorable Mention

Jeff Wittman/FB; SID First Team, Football Gazette First Team

1992

Dave Brumfield/G; SID First Team, Football Gazette First Team

Ed Mahoney/PK; SID Third Team

Jeff Wittman/FB; AFCA, SID First Team, Football Gazette First Team

1993

Joe Palumbo/SE; SID Third Team, Football Gazette Special Mention

1994

George Judware/G; SID Honorable Mention

Ed Mahoney/P; SID Honorable Mention

Jason Nichols/LB; SID Honorable Mention, Football Gazette Third Team

1995

Scott Connolly/DE; AFCA

Jeff Higgins/KR; SID Honorable Mention, Football Gazette Second Team

1996

Jeff Higgins/KR; SID Second Team, Football Gazette Second Team

1997

Briggs Bedigian/T; SID Second Team

1998

Matt Buddenhagen/KR; SID First Team, Football Gazette First Team

Mike Sansone/LB; SID First Team, Football Gazette First Team, AP Third Team

1999

Jeff Erne/TE; D3football.com First Team, SID Third Team

Adam Grossman/G; D3football.com Honorable Mention, SID Third Team

2000

Ron Amato/FS; AFCA, Football Gazette First Team, SID Second Team, AP Third Team, D3football.com Third Team

Adam Grossman/G; D3football.com First Team, SID Third Team

2001

Brian Bicher/P; D3football.com Third Team

Drew Davidson/G; D3football.com Honorable Mention

Mark McDonough/LB; Football Gazette Third Team, SID Honorable Mention

Conor Mulkeen/TE; D3football.com Honorable Mention

2003

Tariq Ahmad/OT; Football Gazette Third Team

Robert Truman/LB; SID Honorable Mention
 

Vince Dargush/TE; D3football.com First Team, AFCA, AP Second Team
Alex Shafiro/DT; D3football.com Second Team

2005
Jose Colon/LB; Football Gazette Honorable Mention
Joe Scalice/OG; AP First Team, Football Gazette First Team, AFCA First Team, D3football.com Honorable Mention, Preseason First Team D3football.com

2006
Kelly Gordon/KR; D3football.com Second Team
Charlie Stephens/DB; Football Gazette Honorable Mention

2007
Jason Chier/KR; D3football.com Third Team

2008
Jason Chier/CB; D3football.com First Team
Chris Gray/OG; D3football.com Third Team
Matt Scalice/LB; D3foobtall.com First Team
Brian Weverbergh/TE; AFCA First Team, AP Second Team, D3football.com Third Team

2011
Dan Ruffrage/KR; D3football.com Third Team

2013
Jared Prugar/TE; D3football.com Second Team

2014
Ben Cary/TE/FB; D3football.com Third Team

2016
Jordan Schemm/RET; D3football.com Honorable Mention

2018
Pat Minogue/LB; AFCA First Team, D3football.com Third Team

2019
Will Gladney/WR; AFCA Second Team, D3football.com Honorable Mention
Nick Garone/LB; AP Second Team
John Hadac/DE; D3football.com Third Team

2021
Nicholas Bahamonde/K; AFCA First Team, AP First Team, D3football.com Second Team
Jake Villanueva/OL; AFCA Second Team, AP Second Team

2022
Jake Villanueva/OL; AP Second Team, D3football.com Second Team
Matt DeSimpliciis/LB; D3football.com Second Team

2023
Derek Slywka/S; AP First Team, D3football.com First Team, AFCA Second Team
Ben Stola/LB; D3football.com First Team
Jalen Leonard-Osbourne/RB; D3football.com Fourth Team

2024
Jake Connolly/S, D3football.com First Team
 

AFCA: American Football Coaches Association